User blog:UndeadHero/Help Starting

hello. I am a new user adn I need some help.

I have two ideas and I can't seem to decide which one to start with.

1) Eta: 80% Water, has pirates and marines basically fighting each other with an ancient civilization that no one understands. There is some magically elements, but not a lot.

2) Altair: 71% Water, Medieval and Industrial with magic.

Some opinions would be nice.